ALKAN: Esquisses, Op. 63

STRAUSS II, J.: Edition - Vol. 38

LIADOV: Piano Miniatures

KORNGOLD: Piano Works

CUI: 25 Preludes, Op. 64

STRAUSS II, J.: Edition - Vol. 39

GOLDMARK: Symphony No. 2, Op. 35 / Penthesilea, Op. 31

There used to be an eminent cartoonist who specialised in using the caption "The Man who........." as the usual title for his drawings - amusing little trifles normally alluding to slight moments of minor social embarrassment that didn't matter a jot in the real world. The composer Antonio Salieri has, erroneously and unfairly, gone down into popular culture as "The Man who poisoned Mozart" based on a 'confession' on his deathbed when clearly he was rambling. Subsequently Pushkin, in a short story, and Rimsky-Korsakov in his opera Mozart & Salieri used the idea and helped it to spread but with the popular success of Peter Shaffer's Amadeus fiction becomes fact. In the eyes of the film-going public Salieri for evermore is the composer who did not have the skills and talents of a younger rival whom he resented and eventually disposed of. Nowadays, of course, his beneficiaries and descendants would be suing for millions.

There may well have been some resentment on Salieri's part - a normal human reaction. After all he was the Court Composer and later Kapellmeister in Vienna and had had considerable success in Paris and elsewhere with a number of considerable successes to his name. Salieri as a musician would have been well aware that he lacked the touch of genius that was Mozart's that he would never have and simply had to live with the fact.

The twelve overtures on this recording give a good indication of Salieri's skills. Clearly he was more than a mere journeyman dashing off a few pages to raise a few bob when a bill came in. Overtures - then as now - had a dual function - to let the audience know it was time to settle down and to give them a taster of what was to come.

Catching the attention was the easy part - a few loud chords, as in the first selection " Il Talismano" and the drum roll to open "Cesare in Farmacusa" would settle the listeners. The other scene-setting element is amply illustrated in the gentle flute passage in "Eraclito e Democrito" and the mock gravity in the episodic "La Secchia rapita" - a tale of a war between states over a stolen bucket, no less. There is a pleasant closing melodic passage in "Armida" and the "Don Quixotte" overture has some double quick violin playing and an attractive minuet interlude.

There is something in each of the dozen examples which catches the attention. Thoroughly competent, thoughtful pieces with touches of pleasing melodies and lots of dynamic contrasts written in. They show the composer in a good light, helped by a decent recording and playing. Not to be played through one after the other but as a reminder of a man unfairly treated by posterity they serve their purpose.

-- Harry Downey, MusicWeb International

RUBINSTEIN: Piano Concerto No. 5 / Caprice Russe

STRAUSS II, J.: Edition - Vol. 36

RUBINSTEIN: Piano Concertos Nos. 3 and 4

GLASS, L.: Symphonies Nos. 5 and 6

KUHLAU: Piano Quartets Nos. 1 and 2

MEDTNER: Sonatas Opp. 22 and 25, Nos. 1 and 2

TOURNEMIRE: Symphonies Nos. 1 and 5